Given all the hype about ChatGTP and AI in general in the media, I can’t help worrying about the future of my profession. Will Chatbots take over the role of journalists? Will computer-generated texts replace the deathless prose I and my colleagues have been producing for years (and which, incidentally, pays for our bread and butter)?
Over the course of the last 50+ years, I have seen one technological revolution after the other change the way journalists work. When I started out, newspapers were produced with lead type, and I grew very adapt at reading texts on their heads, and I was even allowed to assemble a page myself after the Metteur (the make-up arranger, a centuries-old craft that traced its roots back to Johannes Gutenberg himself) got so fed up with me meddling in his pages that he allowed me to finish the last local page; when I was ready he would place his fingers on the galley and apply pressure; if it was okay, he would say „Sitzt, passt, wackelt und hat Luft!“ („Sits, fits, wiggles and has air!“), thus giving my work his imprimatur.
Then came digital type, and the proud Metteurs (they had to be big and strong if they were to lift the heavy galleys every day) were replaced by spindly types and even women (!) who were deft with scissors and tweezers. And these, too, disappeared when computers and desktop publishing came along. Gradually, we journalist ourselves took over the job of producing layouts – not that we were paid anything extra for all the extra work.
Now, computers can actually write the texts themselves, so who needs us, anyway?
No wonder I sleep badly these days. Who knows how far this will go?
I guess the best thing to do is to go right to the source. So I asked ChatGTP the million-dollar question: „Do journalism and journalists have a future in the age of AI and ChatGTP?“ Here’s what it said:
Absolutely, journalism and journalists have a future in the age of AI and ChatGPT. While AI technologies like ChatGPT have made advancements in automating certain tasks and assisting with content generation, they cannot replace the essential role that human journalists play in the field.
Journalists bring a range of skills and qualities that AI currently struggles to replicate. They possess critical thinking abilities, ethical decision-making, and contextual understanding, which are crucial for investigative reporting, in-depth analysis, and storytelling. Journalists have the capacity to ask insightful questions, challenge authority, and uncover hidden truths. These qualities contribute to the quality, credibility, and integrity of journalism.
AI technologies can undoubtedly support journalists in their work. They can assist in data analysis, fact-checking, and streamlining routine tasks, allowing journalists to focus on more substantive work. AI can help journalists identify patterns and connections within large datasets, providing valuable insights and aiding in the discovery of new stories. Additionally, AI-powered tools can enhance efficiency in newsrooms, improving workflows and facilitating content distribution.
However, the limitations of AI must be acknowledged. AI algorithms are trained on existing data, which can introduce biases and inaccuracies. Ensuring ethical use and addressing biases in AI systems require human oversight and involvement. AI-generated content can lack the critical thinking and ethical judgment that human journalists bring to their work. Trust and credibility are crucial in journalism, and these qualities are cultivated through the human element of the profession.
Furthermore, journalism serves a vital societal function beyond information dissemination. It holds power to account, uncovers corruption, and gives voice to marginalized communities. Journalists provide analysis, interpretation, and context to complex issues, helping citizens make informed decisions. These functions require human judgment, empathy, and the ability to navigate ethical dilemmas.
While AI can enhance certain aspects of journalism, it cannot replace the nuanced and multifaceted work of journalists. The future of journalism lies in a symbiotic relationship between AI and human journalists, where technology augments and supports human expertise. AI can assist in data processing, content generation, and personalized news delivery, while human journalists focus on investigative reporting, analysis, and providing critical context.
Journalists need to adapt and embrace AI technologies as tools rather than viewing them as a threat. This means developing skills to work alongside AI, understanding its capabilities and limitations, and leveraging it to enhance their journalistic practices. Journalists can also play a crucial role in ensuring the responsible and ethical use of AI, advocating for transparency, addressing biases, and providing the necessary human oversight.
In conclusion, journalism and journalists have a future in the age of AI and ChatGPT. While AI technologies can support and enhance certain aspects of journalism, human journalists bring unique skills, values, and expertise that are indispensable to the field. The future of journalism lies in a harmonious integration of AI and human journalism, where the strengths of both are leveraged to produce high-quality, ethical, and trustworthy journalism for the benefit of society.